Balance in the Scales of Justice - Does Recidivism Equal a Failed System?

 

Balance
   It is no secret that Progressive politicians like Senator Sanders and Chittenden County State's Attorney Sarah George portray our nation's criminal justice system as "broken." The thing of it is, our United States developed a comprehensive system of laws and correction practices to protect public safety and uphold justice. While no system is perfect, our current model plays an important role.

    Critics point to high rates of recidivism as evidence of failure. However, the fact that many offenders reoffend does not necessarily mean the system itself is to blame. Little doubt regarding complex societal factors contribute a large share to criminal behavior.  We as a society should definitely consider the substantial costs of incarceration AND the greater costs of crime to communities overall.

    While progressives point to high recidivism rates as evidence of a failed justice system, we cannot place the onus solely on society.  At some point, personal responsibility must come into play. Offenders make a conscious choice to commit crimes, fully aware of the consequences (or until recently, a lack of consequence). Despite being given a second chance after release, many choose to reoffend. 

     Why does someone repeat illegal activity after facing punishment?  While personal agency and responsibility should not be dismissed, we must acknowledge the reality that difficult circumstances can limit one's choices and strain moral thinking.  But there is a substantial difference between stealing bread to feed your family and stealing a car for a joy ride.

     Advocacy for additional rehabilitation programs may truly come from the heart and a desire to help.  While increasing such efforts sounds appealing, many already exist.  This duplication creates bureaucracy, confusion, and costs Vermonter’s more.

     While America's justice system faces challenges, repetitive and costly programs are unwise. Providing training and education remain as solid courses of action to reduce recidivism, and we need to ensure there’s understanding of these opportunities and second chances to help “break the cycle”.  Can we build & improve - absolutely!  However, simply making “more” overcomplicates the situation and bogs individuals down.

     True social justice requires consideration of both perpetrator and victim. It means implementing preventative measures before disadvantages spiral into criminal pathways, AND it also demands holding those who cross ethical lines accountable in a manner that conveys respect for community values. Promoting safety and human rights cannot be separated when discussing crime and justice issues. Reform should therefore consider balanced approaches - alleviating risk factors for criminality while also delivering meaningful consequences.  We welcome balance from our next States Attorney.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Navigating Education Budget Challenges: Act 60, Taxpayer Trust, and Continuous Improvement

Image
       Vermont’s Act 60, passed in 1997, sought to make education funding more equitable across school districts through a statewide property tax system. Over 75% of school budgets now come from local property taxes. While well-intentioned, implementation of Act 60 funding formulas cultivates a temporal disconnect: towns and school boards can vote to increase spending without constituents feeling immediate tax consequences. This accountability gap has precipitated year-over-year increases in education budgets often exceeding inflation and economic growth, despite steady decreases in student populations. The unfortunate budget Vote-to-Tax gap fosters a unique dynamic: Taxpayers rarely trace rising tax burdens directly back to specific prior-year school budget decisions. This reduces voter agency and perceived value from their tax dollars. School boards experience psychological distance from tax implications their budget votes ultimately trigger . This can promote over...
Read more

Property Tax Reform for School Funding - Should VT Go Hybrid?

Image
  Rethinking Vermont's School Funding Approach Vermont currently funds K-12 education through a mix of statewide and local property taxes. About two-thirds of the $1.6 billion yearly total comes from homeowners via tax rates and formulas set at the state level. This convoluted system aims to equalize spending across districts, but creates confusion on how increasing revenues tie to per-pupil funding and outcomes. Property tax bills also provide income-based credits for affordability, but these credits lag behind current year taxes owed. This mismatch leaves many families unaware of what drives changing tax burdens. As wages and budgets feel squeezed by taxes going up faster than incomes, public trust in the school funding model has eroded.  Click here for the Joint Fiscal Office Brief on Property Tax Credit There are better approaches. Several states predominantly allocate operational funding to     schools through state income or sales taxes. Others ...
Read more

Balancing Priorities: Why We Can't Afford Tunnel Vision on Climate Change

Image
As a conservative, it's natural for concern regarding the resources of our planet.  The narrow discussion around environmental issues focusing on climate change loses focus on other pressing issues.  Systems theory highlights that one input to a system cannot be discounted nor solely blamed on an outcome....but the media hyper focus on emissions loses sight of other pressing environmental challenges that have profound impacts on the health of our ecosystems and communities.  The current scale and pace of environmental degradation is truly unprecedented - and much of it has nothing to do with greenhouse gas emissions despite the political landscape. Plastics & Toxins      Take the issue of plastic pollution, for instance. Our oceans are now awash with trillions of pieces of microplastic. These tiny plastic particles find their way into the food chain, with untold consequences for marine life and human health.  When was the last time you walked the s...
Read more